Sunday, October 18, 2009

A Year Of Cognitive Dissonance.

Welcome to Harper Day! You remember it well -- that's when the voting public returned this government with an increased minority. As a democrat, I bemoaned that fact but accepted the political will of the Canadian people. (The actual anniversary was last Wednesday.)

Then came the months of November and December when history was almost made but for the fact of the prorogation of Parliament by the Governor-General. No one needs to be reminded how Conservative support spiked upward during the so-called "coalition crisis".

We're seeing that again now: Ekos has the Conservative lead at fifteen points! But this Prime Minister isn't smiling. As a strategist, Harper is smart enough to know both last fall and now that voter expression is nothing more than an example of cognitive dissonance.

Think about it for a moment -- the voters want this Parliament to "work" but what does that really mean in the cruel world of real politik? It means much more of the same. Political stagnation on issues where the government is determined to hang tough (such as the environment) and ramrodding bills through the House on other matters with single opposition party support.

To my mind, that is the key element of cognitive dissonance. Another thing that should have this Prime Minister worried is how his high polling numbers will eventually translate when we finally get to an election. There is no way in hell that the Conservatives can hold a ten to fifteen point lead and they bloody well know it! Once we've gone to the polls, their support is likely to drop in the first two weeks of the campaign. Harper has to solidify the base while holding the middle.

In the final analysis, it will boil down to this: do you feel comfortable with Stephen Harper in office for potentially another four to five years? That will be the ballot question. The polls in tandem are saying "Yes!". I'm suggesting that when push comes to shove that the eventual answer will be "No".

6 comments:

  1. Ronald

    Great post if your were talking about the Liberal Party and some of their supporters.

    The Liberals are polling again at historic lows. Every demographic he has lost. Women are 11% ahead for Harper! The last group. Ontario is 14% points ahead.

    The Polls are not about Harper as they are about a rebuke of the Liberal Party and their leader.

    We have chatted for months and I said when MI would follow in the footsteps of Dion. Parnel, yourself, elf, Bernie were confident the traits and hype of MI would fix those problems and lead the Liberals back to power.

    I have witnessed for over 10 months a honeymoon wasted. Every single time a critical decision of going to the voter, the party and leader has folded. In September he went ahead without his MP's and dropped the gauntlet declaring Harper's Time was up.

    The result the Polls and public against the Party and the leaders went down faster.

    MI is 2 points ahead of Jack Layton who has not moved in 6 months.

    Harper enjoys a lead in every single file/issue.

    Some of those files his lead is nearly double!

    I accept many Liberals can't admits he is a dud, or that the framing has already stuck and is not repairable.

    I have said machinations of the "floor crossing" MP's is not over.

    I have said the 25% is not the floor. Rossi is not talking about the third quarter numbers.

    The implosion has not finished. Next week in the HOC more fireworks may change again for those oversized cheques back to the Liberals.

    ReplyDelete
  2. CanadianSense,

    No question that you have the upper hand -- for now. But a week is an eternity in politics. If the roles were reversed, I know YOU would keep plugging!

    Just think of it CanadianSense how this Prime Minister couldn't sell water in a desert (in Central and Eastern Canada) when he was Alliance leader; and today...

    Stephen Harper has many faults but he does in fact have some talents: grit and steadfast determination is probably his best quality. I intend to follow his example.

    ReplyDelete
  3. CanadianSense,

    Now, tell me how the Prime Minister gets out of his box!

    a) he can poison pill HST but my sense is he fears collapsing poll numbers followed by a voter backlash. Under that scenario, it won't be easy to pin the tail on an opposition donkey. In other words, the poison pill strategy appears to be a no-go in favour of further coasting.

    b) Coasting along has both its advantages and disadvantages: sure, the government remains in place and manages to pass some of its agenda over the short to medium term. But what happens when the numbers become impossible to ignore (should the current polling trend continue)? At that point, Harper will need to go to the voters but how can he change the voter mindset to insure he gets his elusive majority? Again, quite simply, another box of a different colour!

    I don't envy this PM. Flying high is one thing. Translating it into a Conservative majority is the mother of all rubs...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Can you give me an example I have posted he would try another poison pill?

    The coalition was destroyed. The next election when it takes place the Liberal leader is on record against and formal coalition with the NDP/Bloc. (Mortal mistake)

    I am clearly nowhere near the strategists behind Harper in transforming him in a 500k views youtube beatle.

    I have NO upperhand. The numbers and the ownership of EVERY single file including Healthcare is absolutely friggan incredible.

    I honestly did NOT see the gap, I also did NOT think MI would repeat the same mistake he did in June.

    MI needs to fire his advisors.

    I already think he is done (he has realized he can't win)so he will leave after the thinkers conference and let the party fight amongst themselves.

    Michael is NOT a retail politician and his handlers really screwed up in promising him the PM job when they recruited him.

    I don't think he wants to spend the next 12-24 months hoping for an election to gain 5-10 seats.

    Have a good nite check out my latest post, I have the "love triangle" angle....I am so not funny.

    ReplyDelete
  5. CanadianSense,

    Sorry but I did not mean you directly regarding a possible poison pill. As for the upper hand, again it was meant collectively (CPC, government).

    Respectfully, I disagree about him leaving. Like Harper, Michael is an incredible fighter -- especially when you get his dander end. He will fight until the bitter end (either for him or the PM).

    Again CanadianSense, EVERYTHING is recoverable in politics if it's done right. The longer this Prime Minister coasts, the more time we have to take a stab at turning the train around!

    ReplyDelete